Home Literature Index Movies & Broadway Index Television Index Music Index Miscellaneous Index Submit Your Own

Excerpted from “Council Elronedes” in Aristotle’s “Medi-Earthica”

by hobbitfancier

The followers of Hobbitas long ago suggested that the Ring should be hidden, but their logic has long since been dismantled, having been …

...(here an unknown number of lines have been lost)…

And Boromitus maintains that this Ring is a gift to the armies of could be wielded against the enemy to the advantage of Man. But he is notably a member of the simple clan of Spartan men who know nothing of the subtleties of this world, and his belief is obviously pure folly. For the Ring was made to serve Sauron, and its nature is not that of the sword, which is the ally of he who holds it by the hilt; for the sword is pointy by nature on one end, and pointy is damaging and unpleasant to the senses, but the rounded hilt is far more benign and pleasant to the body. Thus the sword has a definite direction of advantage, for if it is turned one way, it can help, and the other way it will maim. The Ring works by a more subtle process (for it is a weapon of the mind, and it is always correct to say that the Mind is more subtle than the Body). The physical nature of the Ring is rounded and pleasant along its entire surface, and thus it does not harm the body of he who wields it or him who it is wielded against. And yet, its power cannot be denied, for any one who should approach it can feel the draw it has on his ….

(here [fortunately] an unknown number of lines have been lost)

Gimles puts forth that the weapon should be destroyed, and he is partially right, but not intelligent enough to complete the method of this solution. He suggests that the Ring be broken and smashed with such tools as the sword or axe, but his foolishness in this is easily shown faulty; indeed, he himself attempted his solution and found, beyond the ability of his mind to explain, that his solution was impossible; for the ing is of harder substance than metal that Men can forge, and it cannot be broken by a material more malleable than itself, as no thing can be shattered by a lesser force than its own.
Thus it comes to be obvious that the only force that may destroy the Ring is the force that created it, that force being the fires of Mount Doom, where flame burns hotter than Man can perceive (So hot is it that we find a new substance in the form of liquid that can be found nowhere else, and most certainly cannot be created through the crafts of humans). Elronedes, who listens wisely to my wise council, thus decided a person must be chosen to carry out this deed, which is of a most perilous nature and may indeed….
(the rest has been lost)